Skip to content
🎉 Don’t miss out! Check out our homepage for details on how to get a FREE Mystery Heart Cookie Cutter with your purchase! ❤️
🎉 Don’t miss out! Check out our homepage for details on how to get a FREE Mystery Heart Cookie Cutter with your purchase! ❤️

Explore Our Cookie Cutters - Made in the USA!

Dive into our featured collections, including our Football Cookie Cutter Set, ideal for creating game-day snacks that are a guaranteed win, and our Valentine’s Collection, filled with charming shapes to show your love. Looking for something else? Use the search bar below or browse all of our unique collections, including animals, holidays, and nature-inspired designs. Whatever the occasion, The Fussy Pup has the tools to spark your baking creativity!

Search

Find Your Perfect Cookie Cutter!

Explore Valentines Favorites

Celebrate Love in Every Bite The Love Collection Find your Perfect Valentine's Day Cookie Cutter
Celebrate Love in Every Bite The Love Collection Find your Perfect Valentine's Day Cookie Cutter
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79

Simple Tall Heart Cookie Cutter 2.75 X 5.75 inches - Handcrafted Copper by The Fussy Pup

Looking for a fun way to bake up some love? Check out the Simple Tall Heart Cookie Cutter! This handcrafted copper beauty is perfect for creating a...

View full details
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79

Valentines Day Teddy Bear with Heart Cookie Cutter 3.75 X 5.25 inches

in stock

Capture the spirit of love this Valentine's Day with our handcrafted Copper Bear with Heart Cookie Cutter. Carefully forged in our family-owned Ame...

View full details
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79

I Love You American Sign Language Hand Cookie Cutter, 4 x 4.75 inches, Handcrafted Copper by The Fussy Pup

Spread joy with the I Love You Hand Cookie Cutter! This charming 4" x 4 3/4" solid copper cutter is the perfect way to express your affection throu...

View full details
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$17.79 - $17.79
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
$17.79

4 Inch Tall Hugs and Kisses XO Cookie Cutter Pair - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

in stock

Measures approximately 4 X 3.75 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of XO cookies! Don't feel like ...

View full details
$17.79 - $17.79
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
$17.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79

Peace Dove Cookie Cutter 4 x 3.5 inches

in stock

Whip up some peace and joy with the Peace Dove Cookie Cutter! This adorable bird-shaped cutter is perfect for baking tasty treats or crafting cute ...

View full details
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79

Pair of Joined Wedding Hearts Valentines Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 4.5 X 2.5 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a bridal shower party? Why not bake up a batch of joined hearts cookies...

View full details
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare