Customer Feedback
Positive Experiences: Owners of large breeds like Huskies and Labs praise the durability and low odor. Bryan said, “Long lasting and the dogs love them,” while Katie H noted, “Much longer than most other collagen-based chews.” Many highlight dental health and joint support, with Amazon Customer appreciating safety for puppies and adults.
Critiques: Inconsistent size and brittleness are common issues. Arianne and Jennifer Kurtz criticized the shift to a thinner, paler product, with dogs losing interest. Cost and non-returnable status are concerns, and julie vna eesteren questioned the value. A video review by Amazon Customer showcased the braids’ appeal but noted supervision needs.
Check Reviews and Price on Amazon
How These Collagen Braids Compare
Here’s how Redbarn 12 Inch Collagen Braids stack up:
Natural Farm Collagen Dog Chews (12 Inch, 5 Pack): Similar collagen-based, odor-free alternative, but fewer sticks (5 vs. 20) and less focus on braiding, making Redbarn better for bulk dog chews.
Pawstruck Natural 12” Braided Bully Sticks (10 Count): Bully stick-based with braiding, but not collagen, potentially less digestible than redbarn collagen braids for sensitive stomachs.
Best Bully Sticks 12 Inch Odor-Free Bully Sticks (12 Count): Bully stick option with low odor, but lacks collagen’s joint health benefits, less suited for collagen dog treats seekers.
Redbarn 7 Inch Braided Bully Sticks (20 Count): Same brand, bully stick-based, but shorter length and poorer reviews make the collagen braids a safer, more durable choice.
Who Are These Collagen Braids For?
Large Breeds and Aggressive Chewers: Ideal for dog chews for large dogs like Huskies or Labs, perfect for aggressive chewers.
Smell-Sensitive Owners: Suits those seeking low-odor dog chews for indoor use.
Owners Seeking Joint Support: Great for dogs needing collagen dog treats for hip and joint health.
Bulk Buyers: Perfect for those needing dog chews in bulk with the 20-pack size.
Not for Dogs Prone to Swallowing: Brittleness may pose risks, requiring supervision for collagen chews.
Not for Budget Buyers: Less suitable for those seeking cheap dog chews due to premium cost.
Tips for Using Redbarn 12 Inch Collagen Braids
Supervise Chewing: Monitor aggressive chewers to prevent choking or shard ingestion, as Amazon Customer advised, especially for small pieces.
Remove Small Ends: Take away stubs to avoid swallowing, as MN did, ensuring safety.
Limit Frequency: Offer as a treat to balance dental benefits and digestion, per product directions.
Store in a Ziploc: Transfer from the cardboard box to a ziploc bag to maintain freshness, as Amazon Customer suggested.
Check Size on Arrival: Inspect for size consistency, contacting Redbarn if issues arise (noting non-returnable policy), per Arianne’s experience.
The Bottom Line
Redbarn Natural 12" Beef Collagen Braids - Case of 20 Sticks are a top pick for large breeds and aggressive chewers, offering natural, low-odor collagen chews that support dental health and joint health. Loved by owners of Huskies and Labs for their durability and safety, they’re ideal for bulk dog chews buyers. However, inconsistent size, brittleness, and a recent product change may deter some. Ready to treat your pup to a safe, lasting chew, like the vigilant German Shepherd guarding a haunted manor? Check if these redbarn collagen braids fit your dog’s needs.
Check Reviews and Price on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate, The Fussy Pup earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you for supporting our work and helping us bring honest, helpful reviews to dog lovers everywhere. 🐾
