Skip to content
Need a last minute gift! 🎁 We've got you covered. 🎄 Gift Cards Available Here!
Need a last minute gift! We've got you covered. Gift Cards Available Here!

Hearts, Wedding, Valentine's Day Cookie Cutters

Discover the finest handcrafted copper cookie cutters from The Fussy Pup. Each one is expertly formed one at a time in our family-owned USA workshop. Enjoy premium quality and fast shipping on these durable, heirloom-quality baking tools.

Filters

$
$
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Peace Dove Cookie Cutter 4 x 3.5 inches

in stock

Whip up some peace and joy with the Peace Dove Cookie Cutter! This adorable bird-shaped cutter is perfect for baking tasty treats or crafting cute ...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Pair of Joined Wedding Hearts Valentines Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 4.5 X 2.5 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a bridal shower party? Why not bake up a batch of joined hearts cookies...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Love Letters Copper Word Wedding ~ Valentines Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 5.2 X 2.25 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a Valentines Day party? Why not bake up a batch of Love cookies! Don'...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Grandpa's Sweetheart Farm Truck ~ Copper Cookie Cutter Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 5.5 X 4 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a Valentine's Day, Engagement, or Wedding party? Why not bake up a batch ...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Heart with Downward Arrow #1 Valentines Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 5 X 4 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a Valentines day party? Why not bake up a batch of heart with arrow cookies...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

I Love You American Sign Language Hand Cookie Cutter, 4 x 4.75 inches, Handcrafted Copper by The Fussy Pup

Spread joy with the I Love You Hand Cookie Cutter! This charming 4" x 4 3/4" solid copper cutter is the perfect way to express your affection throu...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Small I Love You American Sign Language Hand Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 3.5 X 3 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat to say I love you? Why not bake up a batch of I love you hand cookies! Don't ...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Large Broken Heart Cookie Cutter Set - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

The pair together measures approximately 5.5 X 5.25 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of broken h...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Small Grandpa's Sweetheart Farm Truck ~ Copper Cookie Cutter Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 3.2 X 2.25 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a Valentine's Day, Engagement, or Wedding party? Why not bake up a bat...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $16.79 - Original price $16.79
Original price
$16.79
$16.79 - $16.79
Current price $16.79

Cute Hugs and Kisses XO Cookie Cutter Pair 3.5 inches tall - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 3.5 X 2.25 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of XO cookies! Don't feel lik...

View full details
Original price $16.79 - Original price $16.79
Original price
$16.79
$16.79 - $16.79
Current price $16.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Small Folk Art Heart Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 3.5 X 4 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of heart cookies! Don't feel lik...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Small Piece of Peppermint Candy Cookie Cutter, 4.5 x 2.25 inches

in stock

Add a delightful touch of peppermint cheer to your holiday baking with the Piece of Candy Cookie Cutter! Crafted with precision in our very own wor...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

5 Inch Tall Old Fashioned Teddy Bear Metal Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 4 1/4 X 5 X 3/4 inch deep. This bear cookie cutter is great for so many occasions. Make some cookies for a friend or per...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Folk Dove Bird Cookie Cutter 3 X 5 inches

in stock

Bring a touch of rustic charm to your kitchen with the Folk Dove Cookie Cutter. This handcrafted copper cookie cutter, made in the USA, is perfect ...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $17.79 - Original price $17.79
Original price
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
Current price $17.79

Cute Valentines Day Cupid with Heart Copper Cookie Cutter 3.75 X 5 - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 3.75 X 5 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a Valentines Day party? Why not bake up a batch of Cupid cookies! Don't ...

View full details
Original price $17.79 - Original price $17.79
Original price
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
Current price $17.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Single Rose Copper Flower Cookie Cutter ~ Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 5.2 X 2.5 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of single rose cookies! Don't ...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Small Simple Tall Heart 4 X 2 inch Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 2 X 4 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of tall heart cookies! Don't feel ...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Valentines Day Teddy Bear with Heart Cookie Cutter 3.75 X 5.25 inches

in stock

Capture the spirit of love this Valentine's Day with our handcrafted Copper Bear with Heart Cookie Cutter. Carefully forged in our family-owned Ame...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $17.79 - Original price $17.79
Original price
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
Current price $17.79

4 Inch Tall Hugs and Kisses XO Cookie Cutter Pair - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

in stock

Measures approximately 4 X 3.75 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of XO cookies! Don't feel like ...

View full details
Original price $17.79 - Original price $17.79
Original price
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
Current price $17.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Large Folk Art Heart Cookie Cutter 6 x 4.5 inches - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 4.5 X 6 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a special party? Why not bake up a batch of big heart cookies! Don't feel...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Oversized Novelty Heart Shaped Sunglasses Cookie Cutter 6 X 2.75 inches - Handcrafted Copper Cookie Cutter by The Fussy Pup

Measures approximately 6 X 2.75 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a summer party? Why not bake up a batch of sunglass cookies! Don't feel ...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Simple Tall Heart Cookie Cutter 2.75 X 5.75 inches - Handcrafted Copper by The Fussy Pup

Looking for a fun way to bake up some love? Check out the Simple Tall Heart Cookie Cutter! This handcrafted copper beauty is perfect for creating a...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Joined Double Heart Cookie Cutter Three Piece Set ~ Handcrafted by the Fussy Pup

The Small, Medium and Large size double hearts measure approx 3" across 4" across and 5" across respectively. Looking for a treat for a special pa...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

3 1/2 inch Simple Heart Cookie Cutter - Handcrafted by The Fussy Pup

in stock

Measures approximately 3.5 X 3.5 X 3/4 inch deep. Looking for a treat for a wedding party? Why not bake up a batch of heart cookies! Don't feel lik...

View full details
Original price $15.79 - Original price $15.79
Original price
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
Current price $15.79

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare