Dive into the spooky charm of Halloween with The Fussy Pup’s handcrafted pumpkin cookie cutters, proudly Made in the USA and built for bakers who love a little fright with their flour. Inspired by the timeless tradition of pumpkin carving, our collection brings together eerie jack o lantern designs, spooky silhouettes, and festive fall flair—perfect for turning dough into Halloween magic. (As an Amazon Associate, The Fussy Pup earns from qualifying purchases. Your support helps us bring honest, helpful reviews to dog lovers everywhere. 🐾)
Handcrafted Pumpkin Cookie Cutters
Unique, Handmade Copper Designs by TheFussyPup, Proudly Made in the USA
Heirloom Shaped Pumpkin Cookie Cutter
Elevate your fall baking with this handcrafted copper pumpkin cookie cutter, meticulously shaped into a 5.25 x 3.25-inch fairytale pumpkin. Its whimsical, stout design adds enchantment to Halloween and Thanksgiving treats. Proudly Made in the USA by The Fussy Pup, this durable cutter ensures precise cuts for stunning cookies. With 50 in stock, it’s perfect for creating magical, seasonal desserts that delight all ages.
Size: 5.25 x 3.25 inches
$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
Pair of Mini Pumpkin Cookie Cutters
Craft spooky yet charming cookies with this handmade copper jack o lantern cookie cutter pair, sized 2.5 to 3.125 inches. Ideal for Halloween parties, these cutters bring festive flair to your baking. Handcrafted in the USA by The Fussy Pup, they guarantee crisp, detailed shapes. With 49 in stock, these halloween cookie cutters are perfect for treat bags or spooky platters that kids and adults love.
Size: 2.5 - 3.125 inches
$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
Tall Pumpkin Cookie Cutter
Capture the essence of autumn with this handcrafted copper pumpkin cookie cutter, designed as a 2.75 x 5.5-inch tall rustic pumpkin. Perfect for Thanksgiving and fall baking, its elegant shape creates stunning cookies. Made in the USA by TheFussyPup, this cutter ensures durability and precision. With 50 in stock, it’s a must-have for crafting cozy, seasonal treats that elevate your holiday table.
Size: 2.75 x 5.5 inches
$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
Halloween Pumpkin Truck Cookie Cutter
Celebrate the harvest with this handmade copper halloween cookie cutter, shaped like a 5.5 x 3.5-inch pumpkin-laden truck. Ideal for Halloween and fall-themed baking, it adds a playful touch to your treats. Handcrafted in the USA by The Fussy Pup, this cutter ensures sharp, detailed cookies. With 50 in stock, it’s perfect for creating festive desserts that capture the spirit of the season.
Size: 5.5 x 3.5 inches
$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
Simple Candy Corn and Pumpkin Cookie Cutter Pair
Get festive with this handcrafted copper halloween cookie cutter pair, featuring a candy corn and pumpkin design. Perfect for spooky season baking, these cutters are a steal in our overstock sale. Made in the USA by The Fussy Pup, they deliver precise cuts for vibrant cookies. Inventory not tracked—shop now to snag these pumpkin cookie cutters before they vanish!
Size: 4 and 4.25 inches tall
$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
4 inch Fat Jack-o-Lantern Pumpkin Cookie Cutter
Craft plump, spooky cookies with this handmade copper jack o lantern cookie cutter, measuring 4 inches. Ideal for Halloween, its sturdy design ensures crisp shapes. Handcrafted in the USA by The Fussy Pup, this cutter is perfect for festive platters or party favors. With 50 in stock, this halloween cookie cutter will make your treats the talk of the season.
Size: 4 inches
$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
3 inch Pumpkin Cookie Cutter
Bake adorable mini jack o lantern cookies with this 3-inch handcrafted copper cookie cutter. Perfect for Halloween treat bags or party platters, its compact size delivers big charm. Made in the USA by The Fussy Pup, this halloween cookie cutter ensures precise cuts. With 50 in stock, it’s ideal for creating spooky-sweet treats that delight guests of all ages.
Size: 3 inches
$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
Ghost and Pumpkin Cookie Cutter Pair (Overstock Sale)
Spook up your baking with this handmade copper halloween cookie cutter pair, featuring a ghost and pumpkin. Perfect for Halloween treats, this overstock sale item is a fantastic deal. Handcrafted in the USA by The Fussy Pup, these cutters ensure sharp, festive shapes. Inventory not tracked—grab these pumpkin cookie cutters now to create hauntingly delicious cookies!
Size: 5 and 4 inches tall
$15.79
Shop Now
Rustic Pumpkin Thanksgiving Cookie Cutter
Add warmth to your Thanksgiving table with this 4 x 3.75-inch handcrafted copper pumpkin cookie cutter. Its rustic design creates cozy, autumnal treats. Made in the USA by The Fussy Pup, this cutter guarantees durability and precision for perfect cookies. With 49 in stock, it’s ideal for baking heartfelt desserts that celebrate the harvest season with family and friends.
Size: 4 x 3.75 inches
$15.79
Shop Now Shop Amazon
Set of 3 Small Gourds Thanksgiving Cookie Cutter
Celebrate the harvest with this handcrafted copper cookie cutter set, featuring three small gourd shapes. Perfect for Thanksgiving, these cutters add variety to your baking. Made in the USA by The Fussy Pup, they ensure precise, charming cookies. Inventory not tracked—shop now to create a delightful assortment of fall treats that bring warmth to your holiday gatherings.
Size:
2.25 - 4 inches tall$15.79
Shop NowShop Amazon
Large Jack-o-Lantern Pumpkin 5 Piece Cookie Cutter Set
Make a bold Halloween statement with this 5.5 x 5-inch handcrafted copper jack o lantern cookie cutter set, featuring five unique designs. Perfect for spooky parties, these cutters are Made in the USA by The Fussy Pup, ensuring durability and precision. With 48 in stock, this halloween cookie cutter set is ideal for creating show-stopping treats that thrill guests.
Size: 5.5 x 5 inches
$19.99
Shop Now Shop Amazon
Large 5 inch Pumpkin Cookie Cutter
Create oversized spooky cookies with this 5-inch handmade copper jack o lantern cookie cutter. Its plump design is perfect for Halloween displays or gifting. Handcrafted in the USA by The Fussy Pup, this cutter ensures sharp, bold shapes. Inventory not tracked—grab this halloween cookie cutter now to bake standout treats that capture the spooky season’s spirit.
Size: 5 inches
$15.79— Shop NowShop Amazon
Grandpa's Fall Harvest Farm Truck with Fat Pumpkin Cookie Cutter
Capture fall’s charm with this 5.5 x 3.5-inch handcrafted copper pumpkin cookie cutter, shaped like a farm truck with a fat pumpkin. Perfect for Halloween and Thanksgiving, it’s Made in the USA by The Fussy Pup for lasting quality. With 50 in stock, this cutter creates delightful cookies that evoke harvest nostalgia, perfect for family baking sessions.
Size: 5.5 x 3.5 inches
$15.79
Shop Now Shop AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, The Fussy Pup earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you for supporting our work and helping us bring honest, helpful reviews to dog lovers everywhere.🐾